Best Phone Insurance Plans In 2026: What Each One Covers

Phone insurance is meant to cap the cost of a cracked screen, a dunked phone or a lost handset, but plans differ a lot on theft cover, fees and claim limits.

This list covers the plans most US buyers will see as of November 2026, with only the terms we could confirm on the provider’s own pages or in recent reviews.

Buy links go to Amazon or official provider pages, and TheDroidGuy may earn a commission from Amazon links.

Quick picks: which phone insurance should you choose?

PickPlanWhy
Best for iPhoneAppleCare+ with Theft and Loss$29 screen fee, $149 theft or loss fee, repairs through Apple
Best for GalaxySamsung Care+ with Theft and Loss$0 cracked screen repair, up to 3 lost or stolen claims a year
Best for several Apple devicesAppleCare One$19.99 a month for three products
Best for T-Mobile customersProtection 360$0 screen repairs on eligible smartphones, 5 loss or theft claims a year
Best for used phonesAKKOCash reimbursement, no Apple or Samsung enrollment window

Why does theft and loss cover change which plan you pick?

Most of the price gap between plans comes from whether a lost or stolen phone is covered at all.

Apple, Samsung, the three carriers and AKKO cover loss or theft in at least one tier, while Allstate Protection Plans does not.

Fees also depend on your exact phone, so check your own model before you pay.

1. AppleCare+ with Theft and Loss: best for iPhone

Apple repairs iPhones itself, and the plan covers accidental damage, battery service and theft or loss.

Specs: Price varies by iPhone model | iPhone | up to 2 theft or loss claims a year

Pros

  • Screen or back glass damage costs $29 per repair, with no cap on the number of repairs.
  • Other accidental damage costs $99, and theft or loss costs $149.
  • No extra fee for a battery service when capacity falls below 80 percent.

Cons

  • Theft and loss replacements ship to you and cannot be collected in a store.
  • New plans can be bought within 60 days of buying the phone, and one review notes it does not cover used or refurbished iPhones.

See AppleCare+ on Apple.com

2. AppleCare One: best for several Apple devices

One monthly plan can cover your iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch and more.

Specs: $19.99 a month for up to 3 products | Apple devices | each extra product $5.99 a month

Pros

  • Theft and loss protection now extends beyond iPhone to iPad and Apple Watch.
  • You can add eligible devices you already own if they are under four years old and in good condition.

Cons

  • Apple may require a diagnostic check before it adds an older device.
  • Service fees and deductibles still apply on each claim.

See AppleCare options

3. Samsung Care+ with Theft and Loss: best for Galaxy

Samsung sells two plans, and only the Theft and Loss version covers a lost or stolen phone.

Specs: Price depends on the phone’s list price | phones, tablets, watches | up to 3 lost or stolen claims in 12 months

Pros

  • Cracked screen and back glass repairs are $0 per claim on Theft and Loss and $29 on standard Care+.
  • Theft and Loss carries a $99 to $199 deductible depending on the device, and includes Knox Guard remote lock and wipe.
  • You can buy within one year of purchase, though the best pricing applies at purchase or within 60 days.

Cons

  • The standard plan does not cover theft or loss.
  • The one-time two-year payment option is not available in New York.

See Samsung Care+

4. T-Mobile Protection 360: best for T-Mobile customers

Protection 360 bundles damage, loss and theft cover with extras such as McAfee security.

Specs: $7 to $26 per device a month | T-Mobile devices | 5 loss or theft claims in 12 months

Pros

  • Eligible smartphones get $0 screen repairs at Assurant-authorized repair centers.
  • Accidental damage and mechanical failure claims are unlimited.
  • Includes unlimited screen protector replacements and tech support.

Cons

  • Deductibles depend on the device model and claim type.
  • Adding the plan after purchase requires an inspection at a T-Mobile store.

See Protection 360

5. Verizon Mobile Protect: best for Verizon customers

Verizon’s plan covers damage, loss and theft, and replacement phones can arrive the same day in some locations.

Specs: Price depends on device tier and number of lines | Verizon devices | replacement may be new or refurbished

Pros

  • Screen repair has a $0 deductible on select smartphones.
  • Verizon’s consumer brochure lists a $99 damage deductible and loss or theft deductibles that vary by device.

Cons

  • Replacement devices may be refurbished and may contain non-original parts.
  • Verizon revises prices and terms, so confirm both on its current page.

See Verizon terms (PDF)

6. AT&T Protect Advantage: best for flexible carrier cover

AT&T revised the plan on October 20, 2025, and prices and deductibles now depend on the make, model and coverage option.

Specs: Price set by device | AT&T devices | unlimited claims, up to $3,500 device value per claim

Pros

  • Eligible devices have a $0 repair fee, and you can cancel at any time for a prorated refund.
  • A Multi-Device version covers several lines on one plan.

Cons

  • Unlimited photo and video backup ended after February 2, 2026.
  • Replacements can be new, refurbished or remanufactured, and each replacement carries a non-refundable deductible.

See AT&T plan changes

7. AKKO: best for used phones and extra gear

AKKO is a third-party plan that pays cash instead of sending a replacement phone.

Specs: About $6 to $12 a month for a phone-only plan | any phone | $2,000 cap per claim

Pros

  • Repair deductibles run $29 to $75 and replacement deductibles $75 to $99.
  • One account can protect a phone plus up to 25 other items you own.
  • Claims are unlimited, and the plan suits used or refurbished phones.

Cons

  • You get reimbursed rather than receiving a swapped phone, so you front the repair cost in some cases.
  • Reviews we found were promotional, so read the current terms before you buy.

Visit AKKO

8. Allstate Protection Plans on Amazon: best for accident-only cover

This plan is sold at checkout and covers accidents and mechanical failures, but not theft or loss.

Specs: Price depends on phone value | any eligible phone | no theft or loss cover

Pros

  • Covers cracked screens, liquid damage and electrical or mechanical failure.
  • Claims are filed online, and repairs go through a local shop or by mail.

Cons

  • A replacement may not be the exact same model.
  • Third-party reviews are mixed, with the BBB rating at 3.39 out of 5.

Check price on Amazon

How do the plans compare on theft cover and screen repair?

PlanTheft or lossScreen repairClaim limit
AppleCare+ with Theft and LossYes, $149$292 theft or loss a year
Samsung Care+ with Theft and LossYes, $99 to $199$03 lost or stolen in 12 months
Samsung Care+ standardNo$29Unlimited repairs
T-Mobile Protection 360Yes$0 on eligible phones5 loss or theft in 12 months
Verizon Mobile ProtectYes$0 on select phonesVaries by plan
AT&T Protect AdvantageYes$0 repair fee on eligible devicesUnlimited, $3,500 per claim
AKKOYes$29 to $75 deductibleUnlimited, $2,000 per claim
Allstate Protection PlansNoAccident cover, plan fee appliesVaries by plan

Do you actually need phone insurance?

Insurance makes the most sense when a replacement would hurt your budget or you have lost or damaged a phone before.

It makes less sense if you already hold a protective case, or if a card you pay your phone bill with offers cell phone protection.

Read your card’s benefits guide first, because limits and exclusions differ by issuer.

When should you sign up?

Enroll as early as the plan allows.

  • Apple: within 60 days of buying a new Apple product.
  • Samsung: best pricing at purchase or within 60 days, with coverage available up to one year after purchase.
  • T-Mobile: adding it later requires a store inspection.

Which phone insurance is the best overall?

For a new iPhone or Galaxy, the maker’s own theft and loss plan gives the clearest fees and repair route.

Pick a carrier plan if one bill matters more to you, and AKKO or accident-only cover if you own an older phone.

Related reading: how to cancel Samsung Care, Samsung Galaxy cracked screen cost guide and how to switch phones on Google Fi.

11 Comments

  1. How about updating the information in this before reposting it for the third time since it’s original post in 2019 instead of just slapping a new date on in the title and calling it good?

  2. Do not trust Esurranty.com. This is a company you cannot trust. What ever you do, do not signup with company. Here is my horror story: Initial contact was made early August and was good with their employee Sean Hansen, and then it went downhill. I got the warranty and as my luck had it, I broke the screen on the phone. Sent it to them for repairs. Didn’t hear anything back. Sent them an email and was told that it would take 10 business days for Samsung to repair the phone. 10 Business Days later, after not getting any update, I contacted them and was told my phone was locked to Samsung and Google and they couldn’t replace the screen. Wait, since when does a phone need to be unlocked to replace a screen? Now it’s been over 2 months and the company still has not sent the phone back, has not responded to any emails and has basically stolen a $1,200 phone. Also the CEO Angelo has been accused of Scam and Fraud. He’s the same guy promoting his company on this site.

  3. I just got the Samsung S8 thru ATT . Just now registered it with Samsung. Their Protection Plus Plan is $11.99 per month – that is it – the only offering – much much higher than listed in this article – and actually quite expensive. This plan is called Premium Care, and is the only thing available from them on the S8 – the Protection Plus Plan N/A for S8.

  4. DO NOT INSURE WITH eSurranty. These guys are bunch of thief’s. They have kept my phone for more than 30 days and now tell me they can’t fix it for some BS reason. Stay away from them. State Attorney general has complaints against them, as well as the BBB.

  5. Asurion , say away from! They offer Shield coverage, yet when I put a claim in for shield was told, ” We do not offer that coverage in your zip code and the only option was to replace the iPhone for $225.This seems to me like the old “bate and switch”. This was not made know at point of sale at the ATT store.

  6. I completely agree with above poster. I have had all of our six phones insured by Square Trade for the last several years. At first, they had awesome customer service and a lower deductible. Our last claim took over two weeks to get a refurbished phone and about a total of 4 hours on the phone with several different reps. I am currently in the process of changing insurance carriers as a result.

  7. BUYER BEWARE: eSurranty is not a real insurance company. Go check with the insurance commissioner. It’s not real, they’ve stolen my son’s phone. They tried to get me to sign a ‘confidentiality agreement’ to get my phone back. A gag order? Really? For insurance I paid for? Day 66 of them not returning my phone. These are all facts & I can supply proof to anyone who wants. Go check yelp, BBB, ANYWHERE before you buy eSurranty.

  8. Square Trade started out GREAT, but as more an more people used their warranties. they have gotten fat and lazy. No more phone calls to let you know your warranty is expiring, no more GREAT customer service. Now they want at least a $99 deductible for EVERYTHING. And as the previous poster stated, if they have to replace your phone… no more warranty!

    Please save yourself some money and stay away from SQUARE TRADE!

  9. Check out esurranty.com for coverage on your phone. Esurranty covers new, used, refurbished and manufacturer replacement devices. You can pay for the coverage up front and have no worries that you are covered for the year or you can pay monthly.

  10. I learned today that with Square Trade if you damage your phone and it can’t be fixed but has to be replaced – that ends your coverage. I was online trying to get my sons equipment updated (also a real hassle) when I noticed my iPhone was not covered any more. In calling them they informed me that the two incident per year coverage is only for repairs and that if they have to replace the phone once it is replaced your new phone is no longer covered. It’s been nearly a year and all this time I assumed I had coverage on my phone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *